Ramp CC mode in 14 is broken(cannot use Cubase 13 projects in 14 due to this)

[ollyonpiano]

Pitch bend data that is recorded in ramp mode in 14 does not play back properly at all. It causes weird playback, and makes certain VSTs glitch out and stop producing sound (NI FM8 for example)

I am fully aware that switching to step mode prevents this from happening for NEW recorded data, but the problem is that any data that has been previously recorded (i.e. in all my cubase 13 projects) cannot be used in cubase 14 at all because of this.

The pitchbend playback was all fine in cubase 13 using ramp mode. So just trying to make Steinberg aware of this

Thanks (I’ve edited this original post to include attachments of audio exports from 13 and 14 of the same pitch bend data as evidence)

[Johnny_Moneto]

Hello ollyonpiano,

this hasn’t been reported so far. You said that the issue affects certain VSTis and you mention NI FM8.
Can you also mention the other affected VSTis, so we can better try to reproduce it?

It would also be helpful if you could check that the affected plugins are all VST3 plugins or if you use the VST2 version.

[ollyonpiano]

It affects all VSTs in the sense that the pitch bend doesn’t sound smooth at all (it sounds jumpy, not like it is played live). I can replicate it with any Halion patch for example.

FM8 is the only one that actually crashes (stops producing any sound) when encountering the pitch bend data.

My MIDI controller is an Arturia Keylab 61 MK3, if that is of any relevance. And as mentioned, there is no issue when using step mode, and there is also no issue in other DAWs (tested in Ableton, Reaper, and FL and all fine)

Yes they are all VST3s, not VST2s

[Johnny_Moneto]

Thanks for the info.

What puzzles me is that you did not encounter the issue in C13. The choppiness of the ramps have been reported already with version 12 and possibly before. I have seen reports about that in C13 and it is definitely still present in C14.

Personally I stay the hell away from ramps if anything has to sound good, as convenient as they might be.

Regarding the crash: That should not happen of course. You could check for a crash dump file (.dmp on Windows, .ips on Mac) and upload the file here.

[ollyonpiano]

Yes I’m not sure why but in 13 I never had an issue (I wasn’t even aware of the ramp/step switch until I encountered issues with 14)

I will of course use step from now on, but it’s just frustrating that I can’t work on any of my C13 projects in 14.

I don’t believe it is generating a .dmp with FM8 because it’s not actually “crashing” the VST, it just stops producing sound.

[Johnny_Moneto]

If you still have C13 installed and some time maybe you can check there again.

Just for your info: We can visualize the sensation by rendering the MIDI to audio.

The green waveform in the background was done with steps, the blue one used ramps.

[ollyonpiano]

Yes I still have 13 installed, pitch bend definitely all sounds fine in ramp mode (hence why I still have to work on my projects in 13 as it was all recorded with ramp), and FM8 behaves normally. What’s odd is that the actual physical curve looks identical in both, it just sounds terrible in 14.

Thanks for the graphic - although that explains why it would make the output choppy, it doesn’t really explain why it’s only choppy in 14 and not 13.

Something has definitely changed.

[mlib]

@ollyonpiano

it doesn’t really explain why it’s only choppy in 14 and not 13.

It’s “choppy” in Cubase 13 as well. Just as it is in version 12 also. You might have not noticed it though.
You don’t even need to render anything to audio, just use a MIDI Monitor and inspect the differences between Ramp and Step.

[ollyonpiano]

Mlib I’m aware of the difference between ramp and step, the point is that it is far worse in 14 than it is in 13. The difference is night and day. I am listening to them side by side. The exact same midi data sounds fine in 13, awful in 14 - I can’t be any clearer about that.

[Johnny_Moneto]

Maybe you can drop a screenshot of what the key editor looks like in C13 with the pitch bend? It is possible that we are talking about two different issues.

[mlib]

@ollyonpiano

I’m aware of the difference between ramp and step, the point is that it is far worse in 14 than it is in 13

Although I do not have access to version 13, I did some tests comparing Pitchbend data between version 12 and 14. Below are my findings.

In both Cubase 12 and 14 I created a Pitchbend ramp going from minimum to maximum over the course of 1 bar in 4/4/ 120 bpm by drawing a start and end point using the Pen Tool. PPQBase = 480 (default) in both versions.

Cubase 12

The originally entered ramp:

Exported as a MIDI file and re-imported to show the steps:

Captured raw data using Bome MIDI Translator Pro:

1: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 00
2: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 00
3: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 00
4: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 01
5: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 02
6: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 03
7: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 04
8: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 04
9: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 05
10: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 06
11: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 07
12: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 08
13: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 08
14: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 09
15: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 0A
16: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 0B
17: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 0C
18: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 0C
19: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 0D
20: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 0E
21: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 0F
22: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 10
23: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 10
24: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 11
25: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 12
26: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 13
27: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 14
28: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 14
29: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 15
30: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 16
31: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 17
32: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 18
33: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 18
34: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 19
35: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 1A
36: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 1B
37: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 1C
38: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 1C
39: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 1C
40: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 1D
41: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 1E
42: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 1F
43: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 20
44: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 20
45: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 21
46: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 22
47: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 23
48: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 24
49: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 24
50: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 25
51: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 26
52: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 27
53: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 28
54: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 28
55: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 29
56: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 2A
57: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 2B
58: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 2C
59: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 2C
60: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 2D
61: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 2E
62: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 2F
63: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 30
64: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 30
65: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 31
66: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 32
67: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 32
68: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 33
69: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 34
70: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 35
71: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 36
72: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 36
73: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 37
74: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 38
75: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 39
76: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 3A
77: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 3A
78: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 3B
79: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 3C
80: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 3D
81: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 3E
82: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 3E
83: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 3F
84: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 40
85: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 41
86: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 41
87: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 42
88: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 43
89: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 44
90: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 44
91: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 45
92: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 46
93: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 47
94: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 47
95: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 48
96: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 49
97: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 4A
98: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 4B
99: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 4B
100: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 4C
101: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 4D
102: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 4E
103: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 4E
104: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 4F
105: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 50
106: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 51
107: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 51
108: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 52
109: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 53
110: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 54
111: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 55
112: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 55
113: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 56
114: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 57
115: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 58
116: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 59
117: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 59
118: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 5A
119: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 5B
120: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 5C
121: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 5D
122: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 5D
123: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 5E
124: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 5F
125: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 60
126: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 61
127: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 61
128: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 62
129: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 63
130: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 63
131: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 64
132: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 65
133: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 66
134: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 67
135: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 67
136: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 68
137: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 69
138: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 6A
139: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 6B
140: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 6B
141: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 6C
142: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 6D
143: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 6E
144: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 6F
145: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 6F
146: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 70
147: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 71
148: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 72
149: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 73
150: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 73
151: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 74
152: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 75
153: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 75
154: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 76
155: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 77
156: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 78
157: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 79
158: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 79
159: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 7A
160: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 7B
161: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 7C
162: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 7D
163: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 7D
164: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 7E
165: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 7F
166: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 7F
167: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40
168: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40

(166 unique values)

Cubase 14

The originally entered ramp:

Exported as a MIDI file and re-imported to show the steps:

Captured raw data using Bome MIDI Translator Pro:

1: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 00
2: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 00
3: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 00
4: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 01
5: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 02
6: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 03
7: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 04
8: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 04
9: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 05
10: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 06
11: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 07
12: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 08
13: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 08
14: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 09
15: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 0A
16: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 0B
17: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 0C
18: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 0C
19: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 0D
20: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 0E
21: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 0F
22: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 10
23: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 10
24: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 11
25: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 12
26: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 13
27: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 13
28: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 14
29: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 15
30: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 15
31: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 16
32: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 17
33: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 18
34: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 19
35: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 19
36: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 1A
37: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 1B
38: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 1C
39: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 1D
40: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 1D
41: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 1E
42: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 1F
43: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 20
44: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 21
45: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 21
46: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 22
47: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 23
48: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 24
49: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 25
50: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 25
51: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 26
52: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 27
53: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 28
54: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 29
55: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 29
56: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 2A
57: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 2B
58: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 2C
59: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 2D
60: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 2D
61: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 2E
62: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 2F
63: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 30
64: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 31
65: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 31
66: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 32
67: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 33
68: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 34
69: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 35
70: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 35
71: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 36
72: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 37
73: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 38
74: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 39
75: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 39
76: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 3A
77: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 3B
78: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 3C
79: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 3D
80: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 3D
81: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 3E
82: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 3F
83: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 40
84: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 41
85: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 41
86: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 42
87: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 43
88: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 44
89: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 45
90: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 45
91: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 46
92: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 47
93: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 48
94: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 49
95: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 49
96: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 4A
97: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 4B
98: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 4C
99: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 4D
100: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 4D
101: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 4E
102: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 4F
103: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 4F
104: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 50
105: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 51
106: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 52
107: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 53
108: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 53
109: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 54
110: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 55
111: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 56
112: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 57
113: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 57
114: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 58
115: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 59
116: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 5A
117: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 5B
118: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 5B
119: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 5C
120: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 5D
121: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 5E
122: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 5F
123: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 5F
124: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 60
125: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 61
126: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 62
127: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 62
128: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 63
129: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 64
130: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 65
131: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 65
132: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 66
133: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 67
134: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 68
135: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 69
136: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 69
137: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 6A
138: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 6B
139: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 6C
140: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 6D
141: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 6D
142: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 6E
143: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 6F
144: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 70
145: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 71
146: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 71
147: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 72
148: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 73
149: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 74
150: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 75
151: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 75
152: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 76
153: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 77
154: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 77
155: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 78
156: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 79
157: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 7A
158: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 7B
159: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 7B
160: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 7C
161: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 7D
162: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 7E
163: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 7F
164: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 7F
165: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40
166: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40

(164 unique values)

Cubase 14 (Step mode)

As a final test, I changed “Type of new Controller Events” to Step and drew a line using the Line Tool. What I noticed here is that your zoom level dictates how many data points are entered. When keeping the same zoom levels as I had used above and drawing a line with the Line Tool, I got approximately the same number of unique values (or data points). If I zoomed in both vertically and horizontally, the number of unique values increased greatly. Below are the results.

Input mode Step, line drawn using the Line Tool:

Captured raw data using Bome MIDI Translator Pro:

1: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3F 00
2: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5E 00
3: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7E 00
4: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 01
5: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3D 01
6: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5C 01
7: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7C 01
8: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 02
9: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3B 02
10: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5B 02
11: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7A 02
12: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 03
13: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 39 03
14: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 59 03
15: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 79 03
16: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 18 04
17: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 38 04
18: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 57 04
19: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 77 04
20: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 16 05
21: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 05
22: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 56 05
23: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 75 05
24: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 15 06
25: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 34 06
26: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 54 06
27: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 73 06
28: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 13 07
29: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 07
30: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 52 07
31: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 72 07
32: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 11 08
33: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 31 08
34: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 08
35: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 70 08
36: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 10 09
37: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2F 09
38: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 09
39: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6E 09
40: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0E 0A
41: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2D 0A
42: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 0A
43: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 0A
44: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0C 0B
45: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 0B
46: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4B 0B
47: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6B 0B
48: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0A 0C
49: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2A 0C
50: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 49 0C
51: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 0C
52: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 0D
53: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 28 0D
54: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 48 0D
55: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 67 0D
56: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 07 0E
57: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 26 0E
58: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 46 0E
59: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 0E
60: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 05 0F
61: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 25 0F
62: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 44 0F
63: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 64 0F
64: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 10
65: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 23 10
66: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 10
67: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 62 10
68: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 11
69: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 21 11
70: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 41 11
71: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 60 11
72: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 12
73: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 12
74: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3F 12
75: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 12
76: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7E 12
77: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1E 13
78: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3D 13
79: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5D 13
80: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7D 13
81: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 14
82: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3C 14
83: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5B 14
84: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7B 14
85: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 15
86: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3A 15
87: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5A 15
88: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 79 15
89: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 16
90: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 38 16
91: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 58 16
92: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 77 16
93: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 17 17
94: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 17
95: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 56 17
96: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 76 17
97: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 15 18
98: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 18
99: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 54 18
100: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 74 18
101: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 13 19
102: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 19
103: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 53 19
104: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 72 19
105: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 12 1A
106: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 31 1A
107: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 51 1A
108: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 70 1A
109: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 10 1B
110: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 30 1B
111: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 1B
112: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6F 1B
113: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0E 1C
114: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 1C
115: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 1C
116: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 1C
117: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0D 1D
118: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 1D
119: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 1D
120: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6B 1D
121: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 1E
122: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2A 1E
123: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 1E
124: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6A 1E
125: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 1F
126: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 29 1F
127: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 48 1F
128: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 1F
129: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 07 20
130: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 20
131: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 47 20
132: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 20
133: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 06 21
134: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 25 21
135: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 45 21
136: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 64 21
137: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 22
138: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 24 22
139: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 22
140: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 63 22
141: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 23
142: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 22 23
143: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 41 23
144: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 23
145: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 24
146: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 24
147: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 40 24
148: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 24
149: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 24
150: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1E 25
151: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3E 25
152: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5D 25
153: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7D 25
154: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 26
155: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3C 26
156: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5C 26
157: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7B 26
158: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1B 27
159: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3A 27
160: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5A 27
161: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7A 27
162: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 28
163: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 39 28
164: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 58 28
165: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 78 28
166: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 17 29
167: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 37 29
168: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 57 29
169: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 76 29
170: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 16 2A
171: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 2A
172: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 55 2A
173: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 74 2A
174: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 14 2B
175: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 34 2B
176: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 53 2B
177: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 73 2B
178: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 12 2C
179: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 2C
180: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 51 2C
181: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 71 2C
182: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 11 2D
183: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 30 2D
184: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 2D
185: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6F 2D
186: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0F 2E
187: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 2E
188: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4E 2E
189: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 2E
190: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0D 2F
191: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2D 2F
192: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 2F
193: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6C 2F
194: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 30
195: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2B 30
196: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 30
197: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6A 30
198: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0A 31
199: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 29 31
200: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 49 31
201: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 31
202: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 08 32
203: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 32
204: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 47 32
205: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 67 32
206: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 06 33
207: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 26 33
208: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 45 33
209: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 33
210: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 34
211: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 24 34
212: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 44 34
213: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 63 34
214: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 03 35
215: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 22 35
216: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 42 35
217: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 35
218: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 01 36
219: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 21 36
220: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 40 36
221: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 60 36
222: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 36
223: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1F 37
224: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3E 37
225: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5E 37
226: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7E 37
227: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 38
228: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3D 38
229: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5C 38
230: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7C 38
231: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1B 39
232: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3B 39
233: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5B 39
234: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7A 39
235: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 3A
236: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 39 3A
237: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 59 3A
238: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 78 3A
239: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 18 3B
240: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 37 3B
241: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 57 3B
242: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 77 3B
243: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 16 3C
244: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 36 3C
245: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 55 3C
246: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 75 3C
247: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 14 3D
248: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 34 3D
249: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 54 3D
250: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 73 3D
251: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 13 3E
252: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 3E
253: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 52 3E
254: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 71 3E
255: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 11 3F
256: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 31 3F
257: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 3F
258: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 70 3F
259: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40
260: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2F 40
261: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 40
262: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6E 40
263: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0E 41
264: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 41
265: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 41
266: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 41
267: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0C 42
268: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 42
269: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4B 42
270: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6B 42
271: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 43
272: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2A 43
273: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 43
274: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 43
275: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 44
276: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 28 44
277: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 48 44
278: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 44
279: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 07 45
280: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 45
281: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 46 45
282: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 45
283: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 05 46
284: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 25 46
285: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 44 46
286: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 64 46
287: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 47
288: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 23 47
289: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 47
290: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 62 47
291: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 48
292: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 21 48
293: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 41 48
294: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 48
295: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 49
296: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 49
297: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3F 49
298: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 49
299: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7E 49
300: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1E 4A
301: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3D 4A
302: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5D 4A
303: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7D 4A
304: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 4B
305: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3C 4B
306: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5B 4B
307: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7B 4B
308: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1A 4C
309: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3A 4C
310: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5A 4C
311: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 79 4C
312: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 4D
313: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 38 4D
314: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 58 4D
315: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 77 4D
316: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 17 4E
317: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 37 4E
318: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 56 4E
319: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 76 4E
320: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 15 4F
321: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 4F
322: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 54 4F
323: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 74 4F
324: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 13 50
325: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 50
326: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 53 50
327: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 72 50
328: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 12 51
329: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 31 51
330: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 51 51
331: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 70 51
332: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 10 52
333: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 30 52
334: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 52
335: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6F 52
336: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0E 53
337: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 53
338: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4D 53
339: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 53
340: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0D 54
341: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 54
342: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 54
343: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6B 54
344: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 55
345: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2A 55
346: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 55
347: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 69 55
348: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 56
349: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 29 56
350: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 48 56
351: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 56
352: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 07 57
353: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 57
354: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 46 57
355: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 57
356: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 06 58
357: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 25 58
358: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 45 58
359: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 64 58
360: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 59
361: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 23 59
362: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 59
363: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 62 59
364: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 5A
365: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 22 5A
366: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 41 5A
367: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 5A
368: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 5B
369: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 5B
370: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3F 5B
371: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 5B
372: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 5B
373: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1E 5C
374: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3E 5C
375: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5D 5C
376: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7D 5C
377: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1C 5D
378: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3C 5D
379: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5C 5D
380: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7B 5D
381: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1B 5E
382: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3A 5E
383: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5A 5E
384: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 79 5E
385: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 5F
386: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 38 5F
387: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 58 5F
388: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 78 5F
389: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 17 60
390: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 37 60
391: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 56 60
392: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 76 60
393: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 15 61
394: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 61
395: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 55 61
396: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 74 61
397: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 14 62
398: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 62
399: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 53 62
400: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 72 62
401: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 12 63
402: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 63
403: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 51 63
404: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 71 63
405: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 10 64
406: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 30 64
407: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4F 64
408: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6F 64
409: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0E 65
410: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 65
411: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4E 65
412: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 65
413: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0D 66
414: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 66
415: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 66
416: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6B 66
417: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 67
418: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2B 67
419: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 67
420: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6A 67
421: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 68
422: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 29 68
423: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 48 68
424: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 68
425: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 07 69
426: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 69
427: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 47 69
428: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 69
429: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 06 6A
430: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 25 6A
431: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 45 6A
432: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 64 6A
433: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 6B
434: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 24 6B
435: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 6B
436: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 63 6B
437: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 6C
438: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 22 6C
439: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 41 6C
440: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 6C
441: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 01 6D
442: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 6D
443: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 40 6D
444: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 6D
445: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 6D
446: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1E 6E
447: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3E 6E
448: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5D 6E
449: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7D 6E
450: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1D 6F
451: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3C 6F
452: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5C 6F
453: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7B 6F
454: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 1B 70
455: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 3A 70
456: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5A 70
457: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7A 70
458: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 19 71
459: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 39 71
460: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 58 71
461: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 78 71
462: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 17 72
463: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 37 72
464: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 57 72
465: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 76 72
466: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 16 73
467: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 35 73
468: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 55 73
469: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 74 73
470: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 14 74
471: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 33 74
472: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 53 74
473: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 73 74
474: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 12 75
475: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 32 75
476: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 51 75
477: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 71 75
478: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 10 76
479: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 30 76
480: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 50 76
481: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6F 76
482: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0F 77
483: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2E 77
484: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4E 77
485: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6D 77
486: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0D 78
487: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2C 78
488: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4C 78
489: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6C 78
490: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 0B 79
491: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 2B 79
492: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 4A 79
493: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 6A 79
494: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 09 7A
495: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 29 7A
496: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 49 7A
497: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 68 7A
498: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 08 7B
499: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 27 7B
500: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 47 7B
501: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 66 7B
502: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 06 7C
503: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 26 7C
504: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 45 7C
505: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 65 7C
506: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 04 7D
507: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 24 7D
508: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 43 7D
509: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 63 7D
510: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 02 7E
511: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 22 7E
512: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 42 7E
513: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 61 7E
514: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 01 7F
515: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 20 7F
516: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 40 7F
517: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 5F 7F
518: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 7F 7F
519: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40
520: MIDI IN [AHK]: E0 00 40

Conclusion

The Ramp results from Cubase 12 and 14 are not identical although the tests were performed identically. Both the values and the number of values differ. However the number of values are close. 166 for Cubase 12 compared to 164 in Cubase 14. The big surprise for me was the results of setting the input mode to Step and observing that zoom levels impacted the amount of data entered using the Line Tool. This prompted me to perform a 4th test: switching over to Ramp again and enter points using the same zoom levels as in the previous test. In this case, zoom levels did not appear to have an impact on the amount of data entered and I saw the same number of unique values as was observed using the lower zoom levels with Ramp.

End of test.

[ollyonpiano]

Here are audio exports of the same pitch bend data (both in ramp mode) from C13 and C14. As you can hear, the one in 14 is a disaster and the one in 13 sounds fine.

[mlib]

No, that doesn’t sound right.
Would you mind sharing the MIDI file?

[ollyonpiano]

pitchbend13.mid (3.3 KB)
pitchbend14.mid (5.7 KB)

Right so here is the interesting bit. I export the midi file from 13, and it looks, and sounds, normal as you can see. But if I export it in 14, the curve now has these random dips, as if data points are just missing, which is what is causing the “glitchy” sound in the audio.

[mlib]

Strange. I haven’t experienced the glitchy behavior you are seeing.
Were these tests done in a blank project? Perhaps try starting Cubase in Safe Mode with Preferences disabled?
I don’t think this is related to Step/Ramp.

[ollyonpiano]

Here are 3 screenshots.

1. Recorded in step (looks, and sounds, fine)
2. Recorded in ramp (LOOKS fine, sounds glitchy)
3. Export of ramp (looks how it sounds…glitchy)
   
   
   
   
   

The only reason for me being able to replicate this 100% of the time and you not I can think of would be a difference of MIDI controllers., and perhaps ramp mode is just not reading the MIDI data that is sent properly. But again, this is only apparent in C14 and not C13, which takes us full circle back to the original point.
To me though it LOOKS like C14 is adding in data points that were never sent (i.e. these jumps to zero or extremes) when recording in ramp mode.

Either way, surely Steinberg might want to look at this?

[Johnny_Moneto]

@ollyonpiano

The only reason for me being able to replicate this 100% of the time and you not I can think of would be a difference of MIDI controllers., and perhaps ramp mode is just not reading the MIDI data that is sent properly.

I tried to replicate the issue on my machine - no luck. I don’t get the glitches.
What I find most curious is that the ramps do not display the glitches but you can hear them.

Maybe you can try using factory settings for the preferences. Here’s a little guide how to rename the folder:

Cubase 14 Pro - Groove Agent 5 - Modulation BUG

I would recommend to use Cubase factory settings. Quit Cubase, rename the folder Cubase 14_64, restart Cubase. Find the folder here: Mac OS X Go to “Your Username/Library/Preferences” Please note: Since Mac OS X 10.7 (Lion), the user’s Library folder is hidden! Here is how to access it: In the menu bar of Mac OS X click on “Go”. While the menu is folded out holding down the [ alt ] key (options) will show the “Library” entry. Windows Press the Windows logo key + R simultaneously to open …

Renaming the folder has the advantage that, in case nothing changes, you can easily retrieve your old settings.

BTW - while renaming the preferences folder it might also be a good idea to rename the profile folder. Look for the folder “Application Files”. Rename any Cubase folders inside.

[ollyonpiano]

I think I will probably just continue using C13 for my already-recorded projects and use step mode for future C14 ones. I will try your suggestion at some point.

Thanks both of you for your time and help, appreciate it.

[mk1x86]

I suspect this is correlated to your buffer size. Ramp data is eventually only evaluated once per buffer while lots of CC changes are actually triggered per sample.

Just an idea what it might be.

[Johnny_Moneto]

@mk1x86

Ramp data is eventually only evaluated once per buffer

My tests do not support this statement. The resulting audio is the same, independent of the buffer size. How did you come to this conclusion?