I actually think this is a pretty good idea. As already discussed, Discourse is obviously not the ideal format for it, but still could be useful I think. Since there were so few gigs and live performances, I had started a thread during quarantine where people posted what they had been writing (not even gonna link to it here, let it die) and I definitely enjoyed hearing what others were doing with Dorico. A few thoughts:
-
“I would also look for it to contain Dorico scores, rather than sound files” I think trying to insist on this requirement would be tricky. Most pro composers/arrangers won’t post a Dorico file, and many professional copyists won’t either as they are protective of their settings. There certainly would be font formatting issues too. Limiting it to Dorico files would likely limit it to amateurs using Dorico defaults in terms of new work. That’s not necessarily bad if amateurs are looking for feedback, but may limit the instructional value.
-
Most of us learned to write by studying scores, creating score reductions, etc. There certainly could be a useful thread where some public domain scores engraved with Dorico could be posted for study. @Stephen_Taylor generously posted his Dorico files for the Rite of Spring a couple of years ago. There’s certainly nothing stopping anyone from taking a public domain score off IMSLP, engraving it with Dorico, and posting it here or elsewhere.
-
"As we all know, we sometimes hear something - a phrase, harmony, counterpoint, or whatever - and wonder, “how did he/she achieve that?” Maybe instead of full scores, there could be an orchestration study aspect to the thread. A user could post Dorico file of just a passage that exhibits an interesting technique or device along with analysis of it.
“I’m just putting this out there as an idea.” Instead of a discussion (this is post 32 LOL) about the possibility of such a thread, start one! If it’s useful and interesting, people will join in. You could start by posting something original or something public domain that you find interesting.