Organ!

Just to clarify, are we talking about playING techniques, or playBACK techniques? The former is created in write mode, and is a visual indication in the score, which links to a playBACK technique.

Which speaks to the need for improved clarification that you already pointed out.

3 Likes

the playING techniques of course incorporate playBACK techniques. That’s why the PlayING Techniques from the Engrave menu (completely the wrong place for it imho but never mind) is the best place to create new ones so they appear in the score and there they can be linked to the appropriate playBACK techniques which is what you see in the Expression Maps and what you see in the tooltips when hovering with the mouse over the PlayING techniques in Write mode. Don’t worry, @Axel , it took me a while before I understood all this.

2 Likes

Thanks a lot !

Indeed it is very confusing! Hopefully all of this will be clarified and unified in v4!

hmm… I will have to learn what an endpoint is :wink:

Thanks dko22, I started to tell myself that I was totally stupid :wink:
You said “the best place”… Would there be another ?!

I expect you’ve already worked this out but the screenshot below shows that the playBACK techniques are part of the playING technique dialog but it doesn’t work the other way round.

To answer your question directly, you could create a keyboard shortcut for Engrave–> Playing techniques shortcuts but why bother…

How much of all this will be addressed with the initial release of v4 is anyone’s guess. The thing is, there nothing wrong with the functionality in my view, it’s really just ensuring that the terminology is clear and clearly documented.

It’s now clear… thank’s to you !

thanks for information

Welcome to the forum, @Path_to_Grow !

Thank you for your help ! Here is the resultat :
https://soundcloud.com/axel-casadesus/toccata
https://u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZgfJNXZlDB0R8RVhwJynyMTSiHPspNWWXs7

1 Like

I tried to learn to play the organ briefly at school which was a very BAD idea as I had more than enough problems putting two hands together before adding feet. However this is a remarkably compelling work for an organ agnostic. Certainly more interesting than the endless output of a certain composer beginning with B (now he hides under a rock… :grinning: )

1 Like

Thanks and LOL ! I’m agnostic as well, but I love organ :wink:

https://soundcloud.com/axel-casadesus

for his safety, he better stay under the aforementioned rock for a while, lol.

them’s fightin’ words!

carefully chosen – I know there are a lot of Baroque fans hereabouts.

1 Like

I think you know this (hence your joke to begin with) but for the benefit of anyone who is not at all familiar with the wonderful world that is the pipe organ:

Bach is to the organ, what Webern is to Serialism, or Haydn is to the String Quartet, Wagner or Verdi to Opera, or Beethoven to the Symphony… you simply couldn’t imagine the genre at all had these towering greats not come along… Obviously organ music existed before Bach (and the symphony before Beethoven), but he brought it to such a new perfection and level of virtuosity that he created a whole new foundation upon which everything that came after him now stands.

I’ll just leave you with one of my favorite advent postludes: his fugue over the cantus firmus of Nun Komm der Heiden Heiland.

https://youtu.be/vcMXokMoeLQ

4 Likes

whatever made you think I was referring to Bach? :grinning:

Anyway I might well agree about Bach and the organ and indeed Webern to serialism. I would put different names for all the other categories (in fact one name in a different category). But there are other places for such discussions.

1 Like

I will soon post my toccata on this wonderful theme !

1 Like

Here we are :wink:
https://soundcloud.com/axel-casadesus/choral-toccata-pour-orgue-sur-nun-komm-der-heiden-heiland

4 Likes

Is it possible to have an organ “player” that picks up a different instrument? For example, the player could hold an oboe and a flute, then swap between them. I know this doesn’t allow multiple stops, nor does it work (probably) with different instrument sounds on different voices…